Love Project Runway? Pick your 3 favorite designers and compete in the Fantasy Game!

Fafa Forums

A capital WTF for the top/bottom picks?!

  • #  
    Posted September 4th, 2009 by Todd    
    Was it just me and the 2 people I was watching with... or were those picks for top and bottom WAAAAAAY off? That effing neoprene thing was not avant garde, had a last minute stain added to it,, and was not constructed AT ALL?? It looked all lumpy.

    i have a bad feeling they did that just so they could pull the all too obvious trick of having mitchell on top and booting him anyways.
  • #  
    Posted September 4th, 2009 by perfectjohn_is_Gaga_crazy    
    I agree, I hated that dress (or maybe I just didn't get it). Reminded me of that dress kenley did last year that I didn't get, which is why I believe they genuinely liked it.
  • #  
    Posted September 4th, 2009 by Madsally
    That dress of Kenley's last year was a joke....oh I couldn't believe how proud she was of it. I would of worn tonights dress any day over Kenley's
  • #  
    Posted September 4th, 2009 by MartiniDean
    Oh, yes. That was a joke! The judges are on crack or something. I think the obvious trick theory is a good one.

    And how sad they kicked the two most avant garde designers off right before they do an avant garde challenge. Pretty silly.

    Only the sight of Tim in sandals managed to salvage the episode. But things sure seem to be slipping.
  • #  
    Posted September 4th, 2009 by saucybetty
    I actually liked the neoprene dress, but I have to say there weren't really strong designs or spectacularly awful ones either. I was surprised that Max Azria praised the brown avant garde number the meth addict did. That thing was a hairball for sure.
  • #  
    Posted September 4th, 2009 by luna_goddess    
    i was not impressed with Irina & Johnny at all.. Ramon's other dress (the non-neoprene one) I thought was good.

    I liked Shirin & Carol Hannah the best. and Louise & Althea's black dress was to die for :)
  • #  
    Posted September 4th, 2009 by kr8zygurl
    Todd,i was with you on those,ick.That blobby stained neoprene dress was awful.I'm glad they finally got rid of Mitchell tho cause he sucked ass.
  • #  
    Posted September 4th, 2009 by MrtinigrlHATESFaFaCheaters    
    luna_goddess, I am with you on that black dress. OMG, I would wear that.
    And I was surprised that Shirin and Carol were not in the top.

    I think they (production) realized Mitchell was so so so bad and they should have removed him week 1 if not 2, so they found a way to do it. And since Ra'mon got screwed doing all the work, they wanted to reward him. But I am all about the small print at the end of the show that says something about production making some decisions regarding who is eliminated. This is why we see so many "characters" make it further than they should.
  • #  
    Posted September 5th, 2009 by ScottNC
    The neoprene 'thing' looked like a last minute attempt to me. Their other dress was nice but it was all about fabric choice.

    My fave was Christopher and Logan's avant gard look. Scary and cool at the same time.

    It was a weird episode for sure.
  • #  
    Posted September 5th, 2009 by TonIsntGayShesBILIARIOUS    
    My mom and I watched the ep last night and I was flabbergasted!!!! I thought I was having a moment of temporary dyslexia!

    I also though the dyeing of the neoprene was last minute and did not "get" how that was avant garde. The design itself wasn't, the one dye spot wasn't, so was it using the neoprene itself as a material what did it? When Nina was talking about it, I figured it had to be an unusual type of material or something...LOVED Ra'Mon's "inspired by" design tho, thought the colors were gorgeous but there were quite a few other avant garde looks that were WAY better

    Can wait for you guys to put this duel up, I'm thinking WE would not agree on this week's panel.
  • #  
    Posted September 6th, 2009 by debrarae
    Actually, I agree with the judges in who was 'kicked off'.

    Mitchell didn't do anything that was 'actually seen on the Runway', and stated straight up he felt that Ramon would carry him through the challange.

    My personal feeling though was that there should have been a double elimination from the week before of BOTH Malvin, and Mitchell. (so we wouldn't have to endure him 'this week')

    On the Neon dress, there are fundamental differences between his dress and Kenley's clothing. Kenley's dress was too 'different' fabrics, as compared to Ramon's dyed fabric. And it was a slightly different fit.

    My guess is although Ramon won't make it to the final three, is that he will get far in the overall competition.

    As for Epperson, he needed to be a team player (instead of the Team bully). And yes I agree with the judges that Qristal needed to stand up to him (which she obviously didn't do).
  • #  
    Posted September 6th, 2009 by TonIsntGayShesBILIARIOUS    
    I also agree with Mitchel being kicked off, but honestly they should have kicked off both Mitch and Q, imo.

    But I don't agree with whom they said was the best...at all
  • #  
    Posted September 6th, 2009 by mwall
    I agree there was nothing avant garde about ra'mon's neoprene dress that nina orgasmed over. it looked like she took it to the dry cleaner and got it back with that blue stain.
    and their surferwear look was looked very first year fashion student. it also reminded me of austin scarlet's grammy dress.

    my two favorite groups were althea/louise (their beachwear actually looked like it could be worn to the beach!) and logan/christophers (even though there's was more resort wear i still really liked it).

    and sure nicolas' garders were wacky, but his look was way more avant garde then ramons.
  • #  
    Posted September 6th, 2009 by Piba_Natalie_FTW    
    Watching the epi now, Mitchell threw himself under the bus. He said he only did the swimsuit (that they couldnt see) and Ra'mon did everything else. What... a dumbass.

    The neoprene was a good dress, but not really Avant-garde. at all.

    Johnny and Irina's brown A-G dress looked all bunched at the top and I thought they would be killed for not steaming it, etc.

    Nicolas' A-G garters were made for a prostitute.

    The black dress of Louise and Althea was amazing though.
  • #  
    Posted September 6th, 2009 by TonIsntGayShesBILIARIOUS    
    Is Nicolas this season's Blaine? LMAOOOO "no taste level whatsoever"
  • #  
    Posted September 9th, 2009 by mommylisa
    I agree - I fricking just about choked. The top and bottom were sooooooo off.
Please Register or Login to add a comment.
Login with your Facebook account: